top of page

Why Gamers Are Split on Shadow Of The Erdtree: What's Really Going On?

Shadow Of The Erdtree’s mixed Steam reviews paint a different picture to the critical reception (Via: rockpapershotgun.com)

Image via: rockpapershotgun.com - Shadow Of The Erdtree’s mixed Steam reviews paint a different picture to the critical reception

Review Summary: Elden Ring - Shadow of the Erdtree

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree Reviews

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, despite its critical acclaim, faces mixed reviews on Steam. Critics have overwhelmingly praised this Elden Ring DLC, making it Metacritic’s highest-rated expansion with a score of 95. This surpasses even The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Blood And Wine which has a score of 92.


Performance Issues and Enemy Design

However, about a third of the 41,000 user reviews on Steam are negative. Most of the complaints center around performance issues and the challenging enemy design. Despite these issues, the expansion remains popular and widely discussed in the gaming community.


For more details, check out the original article.



Elena's Reflections

The Duality of Reception: Elden Ring's Shadow Of The Erdtree

The highly anticipated DLC for Elden Ring, Shadow Of The Erdtree, has lit up the gaming community with a sort of split admiration. While critics sing its praises, giving it a historic high rating on Metacritic, Steam’s user reviews tell a different story.


Critical Acclaim vs. User Feedback

One glance at the ratings and you might think it's a done deal: critics love it. With a staggering 95 on Metacritic, it's clear the critics found something magical. This rating even surpasses the beloved Blood and Wine DLC from The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.


Performance Woes

However, user reviews on Steam paint a less rosy picture. About a third of these 41,000 reviews are negative. What's the rub? The main gripes seem to be performance issues and overbearing enemy design. For players, these issues tarnish the experience, making it harder to enjoy the new content fully.


The Balancing Act

This dichotomy raises an interesting point about the gaming experience. Critics often have access to high-end tech, which might shield them from the performance issues regular players face. This gap can make reviews feel out of touch for the average gamer. And enemy design? Well, that's always a subjective matter. What’s challenging for some can be exhilarating for others.


Looking Forward

The mixed reception for Shadow Of The Erdtree highlights the need for developers to listen to their core audience. Addressing performance issues should be a priority. It’s worth noting that FromSoftware has a solid track record of updates, so there’s hope on the horizon.


If you’re looking to dive into more details about these reviews, check out this article for a comprehensive breakdown.


In the meantime, whether you’re a critic praising its narrative and design, or a gamer wrestling with its technical flaws, Shadow Of The Erdtree is sparking some very interesting conversations. 🎮



Comments

bottom of page