top of page

What's Really Behind the Mixed Feelings on Shadow Of The Erdtree? 🌳🔍

Shadow Of The Erdtree’s mixed Steam reviews paint a different picture to the critical reception (Via: rockpapershotgun.com)

Image via: rockpapershotgun.com - Shadow Of The Erdtree’s mixed Steam reviews paint a different picture to the critical reception

Shadow Of The Erdtree: Mixed Reviews Despite Critical Acclaim

Shadow Of The Erdtree is the latest Elden Ring DLC, and while it has garnered stellar reviews from critics, its reception on Steam tells a different story. Critics have praised the DLC, earning it a whopping 95 on Metacritic, surpassing even The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt's Blood And Wine expansion, which scored 92.


Performance and Enemy Design Concerns

Despite these accolades, users on Steam aren't as impressed. Around a third of the 41,000 user reviews have been negative, citing issues such as performance problems and challenging enemy designs. This has resulted in a ‘mixed’ review rating on the platform.


For more details, check out the original article.



Robbie's Take

Shadow Of The Erdtree: A Deep Dive into the Mixed Reviews

Despite its critical acclaim, Shadow Of The Erdtree has sparked some fiery debates on gaming forums and social media. Why is this expansion, hailed by critics, evoking such a divided response from players?


Performance Issues: A Common Complaint

First and foremost, performance issues. This DLC’s launch brought reports of various technical hiccups. From frame drops to unexpected crashes, players have been vocal about their less-than-smooth experiences. With PC gaming, consistency and performance are key. When such issues arise, it’s no surprise users head to platforms like Steam to air their grievances.


The Balance of Challenge and Enjoyment

Another hot topic is enemy design. Some fans argue that the difficulty level is excessively punishing, tipping the scales away from 'challenging but fair' to 'overbearingly tough'. Here's the catch: Elden Ring and its expansions are celebrated for their demanding gameplay. But, when the challenge feels more like a chore, rather than a reward, even the most dedicated players may voice their discontent.


Critical Acclaim vs. User Feedback

The discrepancy between critic scores and user ratings isn't unheard of. Critics might focus on the broader picture, considering narrative depth, artistic direction, and innovative mechanics. Meanwhile, everyday gamers are more likely to zero in on their direct experience, including bugs and gameplay frustrations.


A Noteworthy Achievement

Despite these mixed reviews, Shadow Of The Erdtree’s high rating on Metacritic is noteworthy. Beating out the much-loved Blood And Wine from The Witcher 3 is no small feat. It indicates that despite its flaws, this DLC brings exceptional content that resonates with many.


Looking Ahead

Over time, patches and updates can address technical snafus. Community feedback might also prompt tweaks to gameplay balance. As developers listen and respond, the reception of Shadow Of The Erdtree could evolve. Despite the current mixed reviews, the expansion has already carved out its place in gaming history.


If you’re contemplating diving into this DLC, weigh the critical acclaim against the user feedback. After all, each gaming experience is unique. For more detailed thoughts and insights, read more.



Comments

bottom of page